By Mikel McGinley and Annie Weiler
Several years ago, a Phoenix Police Department (“PPD”) officer, Caleb Zimmerman, detained and searched a Wall Street Journal reporter, Dion Rabouin, for over ten minutes. At first glance, the occurrence reads like a hornbook First Amendment violation: an overzealous officer handcuffs a journalist after he interviewed passersby on the sidewalk. However, this case had a twist. The sidewalk Rabouin interviewed from wasn’t public, and the First Amendment doesn’t protect a right to gather news on another’s property without permission.
Yet, the City of Phoenix is on the hook for up to $100,000 for another alleged civil- or constitutional-rights violation. However, that payout likely derives from a PPD Fourth Amendment violation and an inadequately investigated discrimination claim, not a First Amendment breach. Still, without a bystander exercising her own First Amendment right to film law enforcement, the PPD might never have been held accountable.
In November 2022, Rabouin was in Phoenix, Arizona, visiting family for Thanksgiving. While in town, he worked on a Wall Street Journal newsgathering assignment covering savings accounts and interest rates. As part of that assignment, Rabouin stood on a sidewalk outside a Chase Bank location in north Phoenix and conducted man-on-the-street interviews with bank clientele. After customers complained that he was approaching and asking personal questions, two Chase Bank employees asked Rabouin what he was doing. Then, once inside, one employee called the police, telling the dispatcher that Rabouin “doesn’t look like he’s a reporter.” While the parties dispute whether employees asked Rabouin to leave, PPD officers arrived soon after.
“The Right to Gather News”
The First Amendment of the United States Constitution provides that “Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of . . . the press.” In Branzburg v. Hayes, the United States Supreme Court recognized that “without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the press could be eviscerated.”
Further, the Arizona Constitution’s Speak Freely Clause states that “[e]very person may freely speak, write, and publish on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of that right.” The Arizona Supreme Court has regularly affirmed that Arizona’s analog “provides broader protections for free speech than the First Amendment.”
These provisions are well established and well litigated; indeed, they form the bedrock of much federal and Arizona law. So, when Zimmerman arrived on the scene, it would have been reasonable to assume he knew of Rabouin’s constitutionally protected right to gather news. However, while Rabouin believed the sidewalk he was interviewing on was public, it was actually private property.
Free Speech and Private Property
While courts consider public sidewalks quintessential “public forums”—in other words, space traditionally dedicated to public assembly and expression—courts do not extend that same courtesy to private sidewalks. In Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner, the United States Supreme Court held that the First Amendment protects against state action that infringes on speech rights but does not require private property owners to allow that speech. A private business does not transform into a public space just because it’s open to the public. Further, journalists don’t have the privilege to ignore the law just because they gather news. In Cohen v. Cowles Media Co., the Supreme Court explained that generally applicable laws, like trespass, don’t violate the First Amendment just because they happen to burden the press.
So, can the same be said about Arizona’s more protective Speak Freely Clause? In PruneYard Shopping Center v. Robins, the Supreme Court held that states may grant more speech rights on private property than the First Amendment does. However, Arizona has declined to do so. In Fiesta Mall Venture v. Mecham Recall Committee, volunteers attempted to gather signatures at several Phoenix-area malls. The Arizona Court of Appeals held that the state constitution doesn’t require private property owners to allow that kind of activity. Thus, on any given day, Rabouin has the right to gather news, but Chase Bank has no obligation to let him do so on its sidewalk.
The Detention and Search
Chase Bank employees did not want Rabouin on its property, and PPD agreed that Rabouin had trespassed. So why would the Phoenix City Council unanimously approve a payment of up to $100,000 if Rabouin met the elements of third-degree trespassing under A.R.S. § 13-1502?
Rabouin, who identified himself as a reporter, repeatedly agreed to leave the area after officers told him he was on the private sidewalk. Despite this, Zimmerman detained and handcuffed Rabouin, then searched his wallet in violation of PPD policy. Police can generally conduct a full search after a lawful custodial arrest, but not after a citation. However, timing exceptions exist, such as when the arrest is based on valid probable cause, and the search happens immediately before the arrest. Here, Rabouin received notice of trespass but was never charged, and officers never made a custodial arrest. Therefore, the search may have violated the Supreme Court’s explicit prohibition.
Bystander Video and Investigations
How do we know about this interaction? A prescient Chase Bank client, Katelyn Parady, filmed it. In Askins v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, the Ninth Circuit held that the First Amendment protects the right to film matters of public interest, including law enforcement. Despite this precedent, Zimmerman threatened to arrest Parady. When backup arrived, another officer told her to stay eight feet back—a distance that appeared in a since-defunct state law that was eventually found unconstitutional. Parady later admitted she wasn’t sure of her rights at the time but felt it was important to record anyway. Even unknowingly, Parady asserted her First Amendment right, because she believed the detention of Rabouin, a black man, “was wrong and it was racist.”
The case received vigorous news coverage shortly after, largely thanks to Parady’s video. The Wall Street Journal’s Editor-in-Chief Matt Murray sent a letter to then-PPD Chief Michael Sullivan demanding an internal review and action to protect journalists. On December 9, 2022, barely two weeks after the incident, the PPD’s Professional Standards Bureau told Rabouin the case was closed without finding wrongdoing due to the detention. However, once the story hit national news, the PPD insisted the investigation had never been closed at all.
A second formal investigation later concluded that some of Zimmerman’s actions were at least suspect. An independent oversight review followed. It was determined that Bureau investigators never asked the officer whether race played a role in the detention and search. The Bureau didn’t properly examine whether Zimmerman could have de-escalated a situation in which the reporter had already offered to leave, nor do the records indicate why he failed to interview key bank employees at the time of the incident. Although the City of Phoenix was never required to admit wrongdoing, the U.S. Department of Justice, in a later withdrawn finding, found that the PPD failed to properly open a misconduct investigation into the incident until it made national news.
Public Reactions and Settlement
For its part, Chase Bank apologized directly to Rabouin, saying employees should never have called the police in the first place. Mayor Kate Gallego also apologized and promised reforms in the PPD. Conversely, the police union said Zimmerman acted professionally and characterized some news reporting on the issue as just “another hit piece.”
In November 2024, Rabouin sued Zimmerman in federal district court, alleging various Fourth Amendment violations stemming from the seizure of his person and search of his wallet. Section 1983 is a civil cause of action allowing individuals to sue state and local officials, including police officers, who violate federally protected rights while acting under color of law. Still, Rabouin also hoped Phoenix would train its officers on the First Amendment rights of reporters. By July 2026, the parties had agreed to a settlement.
Ultimately, despite press coverage that centered on a First Amendment rights violation, it was likely a Fourth Amendment search violation and an inadequately investigated discrimination claim that will see the former Wall Street Journal reporter with a sizeable payout. However, without a Good Samaritan bystander in Parady asserting her own First Amendment rights, the PPD may never have been held accountable for its transgression against this reporter.
